The Lie of Being Nice: Reflections on The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse

The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse is a visually poetic short film—drawn from Charlie Mackesy’s celebrated book—filled with soft edges, warm words, and a certain timeless innocence.

Its central message? Be kind. Always.
The mole says it. The boy echoes it. The horse confirms it.
It lands with emotional weight, like a gentle reminder from a simpler world.

But here’s the reality: kindness is beautiful.
It is necessary.
It is the social glue that keeps people from falling apart.

And yet, in the real world—especially in India—it is not enough.


The Real World Is Not a Watercolour Painting

India teaches early: softness without boundaries leads to bruises.
Pliability without discretion leads to regret.

Autowalas overcharge. Contractors delay. Bureaucracies stall.
The world does not reward perpetual sweetness—it exploits it.

Kindness here must coexist with discernment.
Not manipulation, but wisdom.
Not aggression, but clarity.

There’s a well-known Hindi saying:

Zyada seedha aadmi ya toh thagha jaata hai ya toh maara jaata hai.
(The overly straightforward person either gets conned or crushed.)

Many stories prove this: the over-trusting vendor, the employee who never speaks up, the entrepreneur who gives and gives until there’s nothing left.
Kindness without boundaries becomes a sugar cube in a river—it dissolves and disappears.


In Business, Kindness Is Not a Strategy

The film claims kindness is “the most important thing.”
But in business, that doesn’t quite hold up.

Investors don’t extend runway because of kindness.
Customers don’t tolerate sloppy service because of intent.
Teams don’t follow leaders who are merely nice—they follow those who are clear, fair, and firm.

Kindness might open doors.
Performance keeps them open.

In leadership, kindness must pair with accountability.
Compassion doesn’t mean compromise.
Empathy doesn’t excuse incompetence.


So, What’s the Real Lesson?

The film captures a yearning—for warmth, for connection, for softness in a world that often feels too sharp.

But yearning must evolve into practice.
Otherwise, it becomes escapism.
Aesthetic therapy.
A nice quote framed on a wall, while the world remains unkind.

True kindness must grow roots.
It must know when to bend and when to stand tall.
It must serve justice, not just comfort.

Be kind.
But also, be discerning.
Be kind enough.

That’s the lesson worth carrying.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top